I feel really lucky that I have a photo or two of Humpty Dumpty because that was the third grade writing lesson I taught today. The children in Mrs. Blanchard's third grade class wrote their very first narrative; and from what I read, they will do fine in fourth grade.
One paper I showed the students lacked elaboration. Wonderful! Just right up my alley.
The lesson: So where exactly were you and Humpty sitting when he fell off?
Student: On a brick bridge.
Me: And what were you talking about on the brick bridge?
Student: Our favorite food.
There was a daddy volunteer in the classroom and he shouted out his favorite food . . . BACON! So that's what we used in the paper.
(Obviously, not a brick bridge)
I had heard third graders...eight and a few nine year olds, lacked precision of vocabulary words, so that became my mission.
As the story progressed I elicited words from these students about what would cause Humpty to fall off the wall.
A wind.
Yes, a wind; but what kind of wind.
A whoosh.
No. Not a whoosh, but a gust of wind that sent Humpty flipping backwards and landing in the grass.
I do love the eight/nine year old mind. I read several papers today, and most of the children chose food such as peanut butter or cheese to put Humpty back together again.
That's when I asked the teacher, "What time do you have lunch?" Unfortunately, not until 12:30; and here it was ten o'clock in the morning. (I can tell hungry children by what they write in their papers. I think they were about ready for a snack. . . . and the daddy volunteer as well.)
As the third graders brainstormed about how to put Humpty back together again, they presented me with another teachable moment. Buy peanut butter and spread it on with a knife!
Well, folks, that won't work. Kids are NOT allowed to carry knives because they are kids. Then one child said he would pull a spoon out of his pocket to spread the peanut butter on.
YEA KID! A teachable moment!
Then I stood up and said, "I'll give you one dollar if you have a spoon in your pocket!"
Poor little third graders. Some of them even felt in their pockets . . . but no one produced a spoon. Therefore, we had to use two fingers to scoop out the peanut butter to spread on Humpty's cracked body.
In the end, the JIF peanut butter was smoothed on Humpty Dumpty and he headed for the brick bridge again. (That's a circle story, by the way).